When I was a CEO in the waste industry, we bought a new piece of kit. It was delivered and installed. It created a helluva racket but this story begins when we switched it on.
Within minutes, the building was full of dust!
Nobody had mentioned dust extraction. Furious with the supplier - how do you specify a machine like that without asking where the dust is going to go? It filled the whole facility. Not good for colleagues. Not good for the tidiness in the plant.
I was reminded of it the other day, talking to a business owner who supplies dust extraction equipment. He’s 61. To him, the need would have been obvious. He’d have asked the question before we specified the solution we needed.
That is precisely his problem. To him, it’s obvious.
What he thinks he owns
I came away with the impression that he sees the value of his business largely in its hard assets. The property, stock and the plant & machinery.
I don’t know where that view came from. Maybe an adviser told him. Perhaps he came to his own conclusions.
The reasoning is familiar. The business depends on him. When he leaves, much of what makes it work walks out the door when he leaves. So what’s left to sell is what you can put on a balance sheet.
As a description of today, that may be fair. A business buyer walking in tomorrow would see an owner whose knowledge is in his head and customers call him rather than the company. Nobody is ready to take his place. They’d price that in to their offer.
But, he isn’t selling tomorrow. He’s thinking about retiring in three or four years.
That changes the question. It’s no longer “what is this business worth now?” It’s “what could it be worth by the time I leave, if I use the time well?”
What he actually sells
On paper, he sells dust extraction equipment. Plenty of businesses do, and many of them sell the same brands.
What his customers get from him is different. They get someone who knows which equipment suits which industry, and which problems a particular site is likely to have. Most of all, they get someone who knows which question to ask before an expensive mistake is made.
A joinery workshop and a food factory don’t need the same thing. Someone like him knows why. A competitor with the same catalogue may not.
That knowledge has commercial value. A customer who has been steered away from a costly error tends to come back. Customers who trust the advice are less inclined to shop purely on price. And the conversation moves faster when the person you’re talking to has seen your problem many times before.
After enough years, owners stop noticing any of this. You assume everyone knows what you know. They don’t. I didn’t, and the supplier who sold us that machine apparently hadn’t given it much thought either.
Two versions of the same business
Picture the same business in four years’ time, in two versions.
In the first, nothing much changes. He keeps having the customer conversations, because he’s good at them and it’s quicker than explaining. When he retires, a buyer gets the property, the stock, the plant and a customer list whose loyalty was to him. The hard-asset valuation turns out to be about right, because nothing was done to make it wrong.
In the second, someone has spent those years alongside him. First they sit in on customer conversations, then lead them with him in the room. Eventually they lead them alone and report back.
Along the way, they learn why a particular brand suits a particular industry. They make recommendations, explain their reasoning and have it challenged. Some of those recommendations are wrong, and they learn from those too. By the end, customers ring them first.
A buyer looking at the second version sees something the first never offered: a business whose judgement doesn’t leave with the owner.
What a buyer would need to see
I want to be careful here. There’s no guaranteed uplift, and I’m not going to put a number on one.
Building that capability costs money. A capable person isn’t cheap, and they take time to earn their keep. Customers still have to want what the business provides. Some knowledge doesn’t transfer well, however long you spend on it.
What I can say is what a buyer would want to see before believing the second version is real:
- Someone other than the owner leading customer conversations, and winning orders from them.
- Customers who have dealt with that person and carried on buying.
- Recommendations made and mistakes handled without the owner stepping in.
- A track record long enough to show this isn’t a few months of good behaviour before a sale.
Notice that a manual isn’t on that list. Writing down what you know is useful. But judgement isn’t a process. It’s built through practice, feedback and being allowed to get things wrong. Documentation records a capability. It doesn’t create one.
The hardest item on the list depends on the owner. Letting someone else exercise judgement in front of your customers is uncomfortable. They’ll do it differently, and occasionally they’ll do it worse. That’s the cost of a business that can carry on without you.
Why owners undervalue this
Part of it is familiarity. What you’ve always taken for granted doesn’t feel like an asset.
Part of it is how owner dependency gets talked about by people like me. It’s usually presented as a weakness, which is true if nothing changes. But a weakness with three or four years to address is actually an opportunity. Treating today’s dependency as fixed tends to write off the most valuable thing in the business.
And part of it, I suspect, is that the usual advice jumps straight from “you’re too involved” to “reduce your involvement”. It doesn’t stop to ask what the involvement consists of. If you don’t know what you contribute, you can’t decide what to pass on.
Where to start
If you’re a few years from leaving, start with three questions.
First, what do customers rely on you to know? I don’t mean your job title. I mean the specific things they ask you, and why they ask you rather than anyone else.
Second, which of those could someone else learn by working alongside you? Some will transfer faster than you expect. Some may never transfer.
Third, who is that someone? If the answer is nobody, that’s your first decision.
Your business may be worth less than you hope today. It may also be capable of becoming worth more than you currently imagine.
The difference is mostly what you do between now and leaving.
Also published on The Unemployable Advisor.
