Advisory Is a Capability, Not a Service Line

For accountants in practice. Renaming the work doesn't supply the judgement needed to deliver it.

By · · Chapter 29 · Advisory

Two advisers discussing business performance beside a working manufacturing floor.

My colleagues in the accounting profession may not thank me for this.

Much of compliance work has been under pressure to compete on price for years. Accounts, returns and deadlines are necessary work. But to a client, they’re often hard to tell apart from the apparently identical service down the road. I see echoes of what happened to conveyancing.

Now add AI.

The margin that might not last

A practice that has automated well can tell a good story. The work takes fewer hours, the fees stay the same and the margins improve.

That holds until someone asks how much of that saving will eventually have to be passed on.

It might be a buyer, if you’re selling the practice. It might be a client who has noticed that a competitor charges less for what looks like the same thing. Either way, the question is the same. If others can deliver comparable work more cheaply, how much of today’s margin survives?

That question rather spoils the spreadsheet. It’s also the honest one to ask before planning on the basis of current fees.

The familiar answer

The profession’s answer is well rehearsed. Move towards advisory, where judgement matters and clients will pay for the difference.

I agree with the direction. I’m less convinced that changing the description of the service supplies the judgement needed to deliver it.

Consider a familiar career path. You qualified with one firm, moved to a larger one and worked your way up. That’s a demanding route, and it produces real expertise.

But what experience has it given you of actually running a business?

You may have acquired plenty through close involvement with clients. Some accountants sit closer to their clients’ decisions than the clients’ own managers do. But it’s worth examining honestly rather than assuming.

Three different jobs

Preparing the numbers, explaining the numbers and taking responsibility for a decision based on them are different jobs.

The first is technical. The second is communication. The third is judgement under uncertainty, usually with incomplete information and consequences you have to live with.

An owner buying advice wants help with the third. So it’s worth asking yourself a few uncomfortable questions.

Have you chosen which investment to delay because there wasn’t enough cash for both? Have you managed a capable employee who was making everyone else miserable? Have you dealt with the operational consequences of a decision that looked perfectly sensible on paper?

If the answer is yes, you have something to offer that many advisers don’t. If it’s no, that doesn’t rule you out. But it does tell you where your advice may be thinner than it sounds.

My own bias

I should declare an interest. I trained at Deloitte, and then spent much of my career inside businesses. I ran a company in the waste industry and owned a tour operator, which I later sold. My bias is towards experience gained from the inside.

I’m aware that’s a bias. Industry experience doesn’t automatically produce good judgement. A former managing director can give advice that amounts to little more than describing what worked for them twenty years ago.

And some accountants in practice are excellent business advisers. They’ve earned it through years of sitting with owners through difficult decisions, and their clients would say so.

The point isn’t where you came from. It’s whether the capability exists, and whether you can show it.

What evidence looks like

“Advisory” needs to describe a capability, with evidence behind it. If I were assessing a practice’s advisory offer, as a buyer or as a client, I’d want to know:

  • Do clients already pay for it as a distinct service, or is it bundled into the compliance fee?
  • Who delivers it? Is that a named person whose judgement clients seek out, or a line on the website?
  • Can you point to decisions clients made differently because of your advice, and what happened next?
  • Would those clients keep buying the advice if they moved their compliance work elsewhere?

That last question is the real test. If the advice only survives as a sweetener for the compliance fee, it isn’t yet an advisory business. It’s a compliance business with good client relationships, which is valuable but different.

If you’re selling the practice

This matters most when the practice is being sold on the strength of future advisory income.

A buyer is entitled to ask who will deliver that income and whether clients already pay for it. If the honest answer is “the partner who’s leaving” and “not yet”, the buyer will price the advisory story at close to nothing. Then they’ll price the compliance book with that margin question in mind.

That’s not a reason to give up on advisory. It’s a reason to build it early enough to have evidence by the time anyone asks.

Building the capability

Judgement isn’t acquired by attending a course on advisory services, any more than it’s acquired by changing a job title.

It’s built the way owners build it, through decisions, consequences and feedback. In practice, that might mean spending real time inside clients’ businesses rather than reviewing them from the outside. It might mean taking a non-executive role where your name sits next to the decision. Or it might mean working alongside people who have run businesses, and being challenged by them.

It also means being honest about where your judgement runs out, and saying so to clients. That’s a sign of the capability, not an absence of it.

The profession is right that advisory is where the value will be. The question is whether the capability gets built first, or only the label.

Also published on The Unemployable Advisor.


Bring operating experience into the conversation

If the questions in this article are relevant to your business or advisory work, start with a direct conversation with Matthew.


Receive future Insights

Occasional observations on owner dependence, resilience, value and what changes when a business can run without its founder.

For owners who want a stronger business and more freedom from it.