You’ve done what you were supposed to do.
You put proper systems in and built a management team. You stopped being the person who approves every purchase, settles every argument and knows where everything is kept.
No single customer is a frightening proportion of turnover. The accounts arrive on time. You can go away for a fortnight and come back to a business that works.
That last part probably took more effort than anyone gives you credit for.
So when a buyer’s offer arrives well below what you expected, it feels unreasonable. You listened, you invested and you changed how you worked. What, exactly, is still wrong?
Possibly nothing inside the business at all.
A buyer is paying for your future earnings. Your accounts describe your past ones. A business can be well run and still face changes that make its future less dependable than its history suggests. The gap between your number and theirs is often a disagreement about that future.
Follow the dependency
In a recent Radio Davos discussion, the chief risk officers of Volkswagen and the World Trade Organisation talked about how geopolitics, supply chains, disinformation and AI increasingly interact. A disruption in one creates consequences in another.
I’m slightly wary of anyone declaring that the world has never been more unpredictable. There have been some fairly eventful periods in human history.
But the connections matter, and they reach further than most owners look.
You might run a business in Wiltshire, sell entirely to British customers and consider yourself insulated from international politics. That holds until your supplier changes its prices because something it buys has become harder to obtain. You don’t need an overseas office to have an overseas dependency.
The same applies to customers. Suppose you’ve worked hard to get your largest customer below 10% of turnover. That’s sensible. But suppose half your customers depend on housebuilding, or on the same public spending programme.
There are plenty of names on the sales ledger. Their ability to keep spending may still rest on the same thing. That’s concentration too, just less visible.
A buyer doing their work will follow these chains further than you have. Here are a few questions worth answering before they ask:
- What do your twenty largest customers have in common? Who pays them?
- Where do your key suppliers get what they sell you? What happens if that source tightens?
- Which of your costs could move sharply for reasons you can’t influence?
You may find the answers are reassuring. Then you have evidence rather than a feeling, and a buyer can’t easily argue with evidence.
Cheaper to deliver isn’t the same as more profitable
AI is the dependency most owners have looked at the wrong way round.
Take a design agency that now uses AI to produce first drafts in a fraction of the time. Same fees, fewer hours, better margins. The sale story writes itself.
Then the buyer asks how long the fees will stay the same when every competitor can do the same thing. If rivals can deliver comparable work more cheaply, how much of today’s margin should a buyer assume survives? That question rather spoils the spreadsheet.
Falling delivery costs and falling prices can happen together. Many agencies, software businesses and professional firms face both.
KPMG’s 2026 UK M&A outlook points to buyer interest in businesses that can withstand or benefit from AI, and difficulty for those exposed to disruption. So “we use AI” is an incomplete answer to a more important question.
Why will customers keep paying you?
Your relationships, specialist knowledge, judgement or ability to deliver may be a convincing answer. But a buyer will want to see it supported, not asserted. Which customers have stayed when cheaper options appeared? Where do you win on something other than price?
How buyers price what they can’t see
Uncertainty doesn’t only lower the price. It changes how you’re paid.
Imagine a £5 million offer. £3 million is paid on completion, and up to another £2 million depends on performance over two years.
Earn-outs can bridge different expectations about future performance. They can serve both sides well. A buyer who doubts your future and a seller who believes in it can both be satisfied, in theory.
In practice, the questions matter. What exactly must happen to receive the rest? Who controls spending after completion? Can you influence the decisions your payment depends on?
Receiving £5 million is quite different from having the opportunity to receive £5 million. That’s especially true if what you wanted was to leave.
The less a buyer can see about your future, the more of the price tends to move into that second category. Reducing their uncertainty before you sell is often worth more than negotiating harder once you’re in the room.
Where the checklist stops
This is where the conventional sale-preparation checklist starts to irritate me.
Sort the accounts, document the processes, reduce customer concentration and get the owner out of the middle. All of it is worthwhile, and much of it is hard work.
But completing the list doesn’t oblige a buyer to share your assumptions about the future. The checklist deals with weaknesses inside the business. A buyer is also pricing what could happen to it.
So ask your management team a different question. What could reduce income even if we carry on running the business well? Which dependencies have we assumed are safe without testing them?
The answers won’t all be comfortable. Some risks you’ll be able to reduce, such as finding a second supplier, broadening the customer base or proving why customers stay. Others you’ll simply be able to explain, with evidence. Either is better than a buyer discovering them first.
The other side of the argument
There’s an opposite mistake, and it’s just as common. Some owners have become so conscious of their business’s weaknesses that they’ve stopped seeing what could be valuable in it. I’ve written about that separately.
Both mistakes have the same cure, which is evidence before settling on a number.
Your business may be worth less than you hope today. It may also be capable of becoming worth more. The time between now and leaving is when you find out which, and do something about it.
Also published on The Unemployable Advisor.
